January 1st of 2007, my husband walked out on our family. At the time he was managing the Bank of America in Willimantic, CT (a job I had helped him obtain, and the best he had had in our 13-year marriage), and he opened personal accounts and transferred all of our money into them before he left, unbeknownst to me. He also quickly filed the federal and state tax returns. The federal return was $9900 and when the refund came, it was direct deposited into his new personal account, without my signature, and without my receiving a penny of it. The state was owed income tax, which I assumed would be paid from the federal, and which to this day, never was. Of course I wrote to the bank and the IRS and explained the situation. Neither organization did a thing. I filed tax theft. Nothing. I called my husband’s boss and explained that I had 10 minor children at home, that my husband left us penniless, that my income tax refund was illegally deposited in his new personal account. The next day I had a letter stating I was not allowed to deal with Bank of America again.
After I had begged and borrowed enough money from friends to procure an attorney to obtain child support, I started receiving $800/wk in March, which lasted until December of that year. At this point, I was working, for the first time in 20 years and making $300/wk. Sometime that year my ex moved out of state to New Jersey and then switched banks. No one in the state of Connecticut bothered to enforce child support, which was lowered to $700/wk after my oldest at home turned eighteen, even though he was a full-time college student. From December of 2007 to September of 2010 I received no child support, at all, with the exception of one payment, which in itself is very important to this story.
That one payment, I later found, was the only thing that kept him out of a federal prison. During the years I wasn’t receiving child support I was in court numerous times for visitation issues. Every time I was there, the judge would not listen to money issues, at all. I consistently brought up the fact that he stole my income tax return, to which he was ordered to pay my property taxes. He never did. I brought proof from the bank and the town that he didn’t pay for two years. Nothing was done, and I subsequently lost my home for his lack of payment and the court’s lack of enforcement. I had to move, with nine children.
I constantly wrote letters, to the IRS, the state IRS, the HHS (federal child support enforcement), the state’s attorney general, and the U.S. attorney general. I finally, in the winter of 2010, received a reply from a federal marshal who met with me in my attorney’s office to investigate my ex’s leaving the state and failing to pay child support. After a year, and after they investigated both my and his bank records, I was told that that one payment he sent from New Jersey violated the statute that he be jailed for being out of state and not paying for a year, (being in state doesn’t count, I guess). I’m sure he pre-researched this, and sent that one payment for his own insurance. The same federal marshal also was investigating a series of fake checks that he had presented in court as proof of payment (when the order was for direct deposit). I could never bring those to trial for lack of a NJ attorney taking a deposition, another technicality in his favor.
During this time he brought me to court to make me redo three years of tax returns because I received a small refund, and he had a penalty. The judge actually granted that I refile jointly, with the stipulation I would get half if there was an additional refund, and not be penalized if we had to pay. During this time, support enforcement was actually involved, and he found that if he refiled, they would garnish the whole refund for back child support, so he never signed the returns I had to go redo. A new judge ordered that I be given $1700 by June of 2011, for my additional refund. That never came, and was never enforced, either.
As of our final divorce, in 2009, it was stated in writing that he owed $3,500 in child support. That was since support enforcement took over my case. He owed me $70,000. Now it’s close to $80,000. When he finally started paying in the fall of 2010, he was only paying $340/week because he told the court he was unemployed. He had been employed, making $2300/week for a solid six months, at that point.
Last week, my federal tax return, in the amount of $394, was intercepted by the state of Connecticut to pay for the 2006 penalty, which was not mine. To my knowledge, he has not filed a state or federal return in 5 years. Today, I received in the mail a letter from support enforcement telling me that he filed personal bankruptcy and cannot be in contempt of child support owed. When I called to clarify this, I was told that he still owes the money, it’s all adding up, but while in bankruptcy proceedings, he cannot be made to pay. How can one file bankruptcy and not show past tax returns? How can one file bankruptcy and have pay stubs totaling $130,000 a year? How can the state of Connecticut not ensure that my children have food, clothing, or shelter? How can they take $394 from a single mother of 11 (8 minors) who has been battling the corrupt and evil court system for five years and not ever receiving justice for her children? I filed injured spouse. I spoke with the state tax office. I have names of everyone involved, I would be more than happy to furnish.
There are other issues involved, which keep me up nights wondering how I alone will ever be able to provide for the children that their biological “father” and their state have neglected. One is the lawsuit filed against me for a million-and-a-half dollars by my ex-husband, for ”pain and suffering” he experienced having to visit the youngest three children (and only ones he didn’t sign over his rights to), in supervision when he was found to be abusive, a fact we all new and that several law enforcement officials testified to, the other being a dishonest, and dismissed judge inflicting a settlement on me for my ex’s attorney fees – three months after he left my case.
I am so tired of writing for help and being ignored. Neither energy assistance, DSS, support enforcement, the magistrate court, the family court, the state IRS, nor the attorney general care about 8 children who are living 200% below the poverty line.
I don't know how your system works(I am Canadian) but maybe it is time to go to your state government representative for your state government and if they don't do anything maybe you need to go to the media and not just the local but state media.
ReplyDeleteI am praying for you.
I do a lot of editing/proofing at my job, so I might be overly nitpicky, but there is a difference between tax return and refund. I noticed a few instances where you should have used one instead of the other. You might want to go back and look at that. Please let me know if I can help in any other way.
ReplyDeleteFirst thing to do: go to your county office and file for food stamps, WIC, and Medicaid. That should take care of things like food and health care for you and your kids.
ReplyDeleteCall your state representative and have them go to bat for you. If that fails, call your Congresspersons and senators and tell them the situation.
I will do everything in my power to make sure this goes as viral as it can.
She has food stamps coming in...but it hardly makes a dent to feed so many children...she wouldn't qualify for WIC, because all of her children are over the age of 5, the cut off age...I think she has the state medical insurance, so that's not a concern. But, it's day to day living...heating the home, gas for the car, mortgage payment, electricity...and the extra support for groceries.....
DeleteWhat kind of legal counsel do you have? Would it be worth us to send out a social media search for a good lawyer?
ReplyDeleteI assume this will be sent to 'official' people- so I suggest you delete the sentence- he hasn't filed income taxes in 5 years unless you know that it 100% true- also take "father" out of quotation marks- he is their biological father- I understand what the quotation marks mean- but you, as usual, have to be the perfect one here. I hurts my heart to know all you have gone through. It is so wrong on a moral- but also legal level.
ReplyDeleteI think the letter sounds great and I hope something comes of it. I am so enraged at all of the technicalities allowing him to squeak by and the bit about his lawsuit against you is almost too much. I can't offer much but prayers to you and your beautiful family.
ReplyDeleteI'm an author. I would strongly suggest paring down this letter to maybe 400 words maximum. You need to begin it with a punch and then give details afterward. That means yes, you're going to sacrifice some chronological order and some detail, but if you want this to go viral, the first thing that has to happen is people need to read it.
ReplyDeleteI'd begin it along the lines of "This is the story of how the State of Connecticut took $347 from my ten dependent children in order to pay the debts of a man who robbed me of $9900."
I think you need to go through a printout of this letter with a red pen and strike every single detail that clutters it up. For example: it's very important to you and heaven knows it's important to this man's soul that he was an abuser. But you don't mention that until the last line, and at that point it's just one more accusation heaped onto the rest. It may even strain credulity in your readers. So leave it out. You've already established the man's character by detailing the various frauds and deceits. Leave out the unnecessary stuff.
What *exactly* is your hope for this letter to accomplish? If it's to stir up outrage, you'll do it. But if you want it to put pressure on a particular politician, it's not going to happen because there's no directive at the end. You need a directive such as "Please write to Senator Stuffandnonsense at Stuffandnonsense-at-connecticut-gov and ask him why ten of his constituents are spending tonight hungry and cold."
If you can tell us exactly what you hope the letter to accomplish, you stand a better chance of accomplishing it.
Short. Sweet. Direct. And a directive.
Good luck.
Why would your federal tax refund be so low? You should qualify for the EIC, which should be at least several thousand dollars.
ReplyDeleteYou can't get EIC if you haven't worked. She hasn't been able to find a job, due to a very economically depressed area (probably the worst in CT) and lack of skills for the jobs that are hiring.
DeleteI only have prayers to offer! I like the editing ideas from Jane though. This is all just mind-blowing. At least God will make sure everyone gets his or her due. God bless.
ReplyDeleteLetter sounds great! I would make the changes that some of the other comments suggest and I would change "new" to "knew" in this sentence:
ReplyDeletea fact we all new and that several law enforcement officials testified to, the othe
I am praying that you can get someone to listen to you, finally!
This is the worst of tragedies for you -- and a tragedy that our world would let this happen. I agree with Jane as well about the editing -- but also think that it would be nice for you to somehow have a link to you for people to be able to help you directly when this goes viral. The greatest mercy is going to come from the hearts of other parents; you cannot expect much from "the system" I'm afraid. You have the prayers of our family most certainly. I hope you don't mind if I suggest your family pray the 30 novena to St. Joseph for help. You need him to be the foster father for your family.
ReplyDeleteJane offers some great advice.
ReplyDeleteWhen you have a "final" draft, post it here and I will post it on my site with a link back to your site. I'll do whatever I can to help this go viral.
MulierisDignitatemFan Said:
ReplyDeleteWhat a BRAVE woman to ask for editing. Smart and brave, and unlike most people who think they can take editing when they ask for it -you actually can. Anyway:
The paragraph that word is in (2nd to last) has some good power-punching info. in it,...I like the way it seems "stacked" with info. after info. I do think you could do an even more fantastic job with it if you actually made it just a hair longer with a few periods (.) or ";" or ":" to accentuate each piece and a few words also to make just a bit more clear.
I like the chronology of the whole letter, but also tbj (or whatever his name is? -doesn't matter..anyway) has enjoyed wreaking so much havoc, that I think the chronology is a big, fat, Must... lest the human race get lost trying to keep up with the dizzying amount and timing of what he's done and does, and the people who could help get too easily frustraed trying to decipeher it that they just take a pass on the "muddledness" of his bad behavior. Your ability to show the chronology clearly goes a long way in lending you credibility. The fact that there has to be chronology has it's own specific merit and you show that well.
Jane has so many good suggetions. I'm not sure how, but if you could pare down as is possible (tricky without losing the content you NEED) it would be good. As you are stuck writing to people with a limited attn. span and time. Hmm... perhaps think in "bulleting" terms, but write in sentences?... I don't know, you'll figure it out. Personal preference of mine: keep the word "abuse" as is.
GREAT letter.
I am just so shocked and saddened for you. I came across your blog through the Catholic Bloggers network. Wow, you are in my prayers...I hope there is resolution, closure and justice is served. What a system :(
ReplyDeleteThis is so horrible! Sadly, I know first hand (from my childhood) how shockingly common it is for fathers and husbands to walk out on their families, and then do everything in their power to avoid taking any kind of financial responsibility for the children they helped create. I am just appalled that the government agencies you've reach out to have done nothing to help. I feel for you and your family.
ReplyDeleteThis whole situation absolutely disgusts me.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the state doing?
How can they let 8, 10 - even 1 - child be subjected to that kind of treatment?
This state enrages me at times. We pay so much for taxes, for gas for everything, and receive no assistance when it's needed - for real people. Yet, they are quick to hand out money to those who are lazy, dead beat, or drug addicts.
I'm so incredibly sorry you have to be going through this.
Please, if there is anything I can do to help, let me know.
I'm up in the Willimantic area quite frequently.